“Why Are You Doing This to Me?”: Liam Payne’s Son, Bear, Struggles with His Identity — And a Father’s Tender Response

In the quiet London suburb where he lives with his mother, Bear Payne sat curled on the window seat, his small fingers tracing the condensation on the glass. He was only seven, but something heavy had been growing inside him — something he didn’t fully understand, but felt every time the world mentioned One Direction or his father, Liam Payne.

It had been just months since Liam’s sudden passing. The world mourned the loss of a pop icon, but Bear mourned something deeper: the man who sang him to sleep, who held his hand at the school gate, who whispered “I love you most” every night. His daddy.

But grief doesn’t always wear the same face. For Bear, it came with questions — and with tension.

The Rift with His Mother

His mother, Cheryl Cole, tried to protect him from the noise, from the headlines, from the screaming fans and painful truths. She kept the curtains closed when paparazzi gathered outside. She silenced the television when tributes aired. She boxed up the old concert DVDs and interviews — thinking, hoping, that by shielding Bear, she was sparing him from more hurt.

But Bear noticed.

He noticed how she changed the subject when he asked about “the band.” He noticed how she paused when he hummed What Makes You Beautiful. And he noticed how no one around him seemed to want to talk about the man half the world was still crying for.

One evening, as she gently tucked him into bed, Bear finally asked — the question that had been burning in his chest.

“Why are you doing this to me?”

Cheryl paused, confused. “What do you mean, sweetheart?”

“Why don’t you want to talk about Dad being in One Direction? Why don’t you let me listen to his songs? It’s like… like you don’t want to know who he was.”

Her breath caught. She wasn’t expecting that. Not from a boy so young, so quiet.

Tears welled in Bear’s eyes. “I want to know who he really was. I want to know what it was like when he was happy — on stage. You act like he wasn’t that person. But he was. And I’m… I’m part of him.”

A Father’s Memory Returns

What Bear didn’t know — what Cheryl hadn’t told him — was that Liam had once asked her the same thing.

It was a rainy afternoon, two years before his death. They were sitting on her back patio after one of his visits, Bear asleep upstairs. They had argued, gently, about how much of One Direction Bear should know about.

Liam had leaned forward, his voice raw: “Why are you doing this to me?”

Cheryl stared at him. “What?”

“You’re making me feel like the best years of my life are something I should hide from my son.”

“It’s not that, Liam,” she said. “It’s just… I’m afraid. I’m afraid he’ll love that version of you more than the man who used to build pillow forts with him. I don’t want him to chase a ghost instead of remembering his dad as a person.”

Liam nodded. “But I was that person. And I want Bear to know all of me. Even the broken bits. Even the famous bits. He deserves that.”

They didn’t resolve it that day. But that conversation — and the photo album Liam mailed her a week later, labeled “For Bear, Someday” — stayed with her.

Healing and Revelation

That night, after Bear’s question, Cheryl quietly pulled out the dusty album. Inside were dozens of photos: Liam on stage in Tokyo, Liam and Harry goofing off during soundcheck, Liam holding a microphone and smiling at tens of thousands of fans. On the final page, a photo of Liam holding newborn Bear against his chest, eyes closed in peace.

Cheryl placed it on Bear’s pillow while he slept.

The next morning, Bear found it.

He ran into her room, tears in his eyes — but smiling. “Thank you, Mum.”

Cheryl knelt and hugged him tightly. “He was so proud of everything he did. But he was proudest of you.”

“I want to sing one of his songs at school,” Bear said suddenly. “For the talent show. Can I?”

She nodded. “Yes. He would’ve loved that.”

A Son’s Journey

Weeks later, Bear stood on stage at his primary school, nervously holding a microphone that felt too big in his hand. The room was full of parents, teachers, classmates. He wore a white t-shirt and jeans — just like his dad had, so many years before.

Then he sang. Not perfectly. Not in tune the whole time. But bravely.

He sang Little Things, the words catching once or twice as he glanced toward his mum in the crowd. She was crying.

Later, she’d whisper to him, “You’re everything he hoped you’d be.”

And for the first time since Liam’s death, Bear felt not just the pain of loss — but the joy of legacy. He knew now that his father hadn’t disappeared. Liam was in every beat of the music, every photo in the album, and every dream Bear dared to chase.

He didn’t just want to be like his dad.

He already was.

Would you like me to turn this into a printable short story format or a script?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *